Recipe for Frugal Cookies

cookies All cookies are not created equal when it comes to how much they cost. Yes, homemade cookie gifts are a good way to be frugal and generous at the same time, but do you know exactly how much that batch of cookies is costing you to make? I don’t want to be a scrooge, of course, but when choosing between two recipes, it might be nice to see which batch of cookies will cost you less.

Here are some guidelines about ingredient costs and which recipes are generally the most expensive.


If you get a good deal at the grocery store for certain ingredients, then naturally you should try to incorporate those into your recipes. For example, if dried cranberries are on sale, then use them, although dried fruit in general with maybe the exception of raisins is expensive. Here are some other ingredients that may be on the higher side.


Chocolate chips


Low Cost Recipes

Recipes with a few easy ingredients, short or no bake time and few additives can be very frugal. Here are a few ideas.



Oatmeal Raisin



Other tips

You can usually reduce the amount of sugar in a cookie recipe by up to 25 percent without anyone noticing a real difference. Try about 10 percent to start if you doubt me.

Instead of mixing in chips or M&Ms, try placing four or five on top of the cookie.

Use leftover Halloween candy for mix-ins in your cookies. Free ingredients, in a sense.

Sugar cookies can be made more frugal by substituting shortening for half of the butter. Personally, I am a big butter fan and would rather splurge on it, but the shortening does lower the cost of the cookies.

Use parchment paper and reuse the same paper for several batches of cookies in one or two sessions. Unless the paper turns translucent from butter or oil or the edges brown, you can continue to use the paper.

Click here for more articles by Mary Ann Romans.

My Bakery Stockpile

Cookies and Underwear Connect on the Web

Save on Cookie Mixes

Subscribe to the Frugal Blog Are you subscribed to the Frugal Living Blog? With the click of a button, you can receive an email notification anytime a new blog is posted in the Frugal Living Blog!

Just look to the right of this blog and find the subscription center (it looks just like this picture, although you’ll have to find the “real” one just above the category listing ). Click on “Subscribe via Email”. You’ll be instantly subscribed and the email address that you registered at with will receive an instant notification whenever we post a new Frugal Living Blog! Don’t miss a thing – subscribe now!

This entry was posted in Food and tagged , , , , by Mary Ann Romans. Bookmark the permalink.

About Mary Ann Romans

Mary Ann Romans is a freelance writer, online content manager, wife and mother of three children. She lives in Pennsylvania in the middle of the woods but close enough to Target and Home Depot. The author of many magazine, newspaper and online articles, Mary Ann enjoys writing about almost any subject. "Writing gives me the opportunity to both learn interesting information, and to interact with wonderful people." Mary Ann has written more than 5,000 blogs for since she started back in December 2006. Contact her at maromans AT or visit her personal blog